The Soya Story
Soya: the superbean! The nutritional power of soya
By Juliet Gellatley, BSc, Dip CNM, Dip DM, FNTP, NTCC
‘Soya bean’ in Chinese means ‘greater bean’. A look at its nutritional content shows that this is a most fitting title. However, this food is not without its detractors and I address their concerns below.
Soya is best eaten cooked in its whole form as green soya beans (edamame), tofu or fermented as tempeh or miso (see pages 31- 32). This ensures that the variety of nutrients and their quality remains high. Soya milks are also a healthy product but choose those brands that use the whole soya bean rather than those which use soya protein extract – it says on the ingredients list.
Products and supplements using extracts of soya have had many of the beans’ nutrients removed and do not contain the wealth of health benefits of whole soya foods. However, this doesn’t mean they shouldn’t be included in a balanced diet. For example, from a health (and ethical) perspective mock meats are superior to their meat counterparts.
Textured vegetable protein (TVP) is basically defatted soya flour which has been processed and dried to give a substance with a spongelike texture which may be flavoured to resemble meat. It is a good source of fibre and protein, and is often fortified with vitamin B12.
Protein packed The soya bean is a legume – a type of plant in which the seeds grow in pods. All edible beans are nutrient powerhouses – they have to be to support the rapid growth of a new plant – but soya is particularly impressive. Soya beans are an excellent source of protein (approximately 40 per cent) as they contain all eight essential amino acids – building blocks of protein – which we need in our diet because we cannot manufacture them.
But the gold standard for measuring protein quality is the snappily worded Protein Digestibility Corrected Amino Acid Score. This takes into account not just the amino acid composition but also the digestibility of the protein. Soya gets almost top marks for both – in other words, it is a wonderful source of highquality, health-promoting protein which we digest easily and efficiently (FAO/WHO, 1989).
Protein is vital for growth, development and repair of body tissues and is needed to make the thousands of enzymes required for the bewildering myriad of chemical reactions that take place inside us. Every neurotransmitter is made from protein and they enable our nerves to send messages from cell to cell. The brain cannot function without protein and a diet deficient in it can lead to depression, apathy, poor memory, insomnia, lack of motivation and an inability to concentrate.
Don’t tryp up!
Tryptophan is a good example. This essential amino acid is exceptionally rich in soya beans. A typical serving of cooked soya beans (a cup of edamame) provides 116 per cent of our daily needs. A 4oz/100g serving of tofu gives us 44 per cent. One of tryptophan’s vital functions is that it is needed for the manufacture of serotonin, a neurotransmitter vital for good mood! It also helps regulate appetite and sleep patterns.
A weighty topic
Protein is the most satiating nutrient (makes you feel full). If trying to lose weight, eating soya beans (edamame) or whole soya bean products such as tofu can be a very useful way of raising the protein content of your diet in a safe way. By contrast, high animal protein diets can contribute to kidney (renal) failure (Kontessis et al., 1990), heart disease, stroke, diabetes type 2 and other illnesses (Campbell and Campbell, 2004).
And trypsin inhibitors?
Soya beans are high in protein but contain trypsin inhibitors – which means they
reduce the availability of trypsin, an enzyme needed to digest protein. This appears to be a contradiction – high in protein yet containing a substance that prevents it from being digested. However, an overview published by the American Institute of Nutrition makes clear that trypsin inhibitors are “subject to denaturation and inactivation by heat” – which is precisely why nutritionists usually advise that we eat cooked, not raw, foods made from soya, such as tofu, miso, tempeh and soya milk (Anderson et al., 1995).
In fact, oriental foods such as tofu, miso, soya sauce and other soya bean foods such as soya infant formula are, according to the US Department of Agriculture (USDA), “generally low in trypsin inhibitor” (Anderson et al., 1995). The USDA also states that trypsin inhibitors in soya beans are thought to help prevent cancer. So, not such a bad thing after all!
Sapping saponins
Other factors which have produced controversy about the nutritional content of soya beans are chemical compounds called saponins and phytoestrogens. Again the USDA strongly state that scientific studies over 25 years have not only failed to show any harmful effects of soya saponins but have shown positive health impacts in lowering cholesterol and being anticarcinogenic (Anderson et al., 1995).
Phytoestrogens are natural plant hormones found in many fruits, vegetables, dried beans, peas and wholegrains. Phytoestrogens in soya (called isoflavones) are responsible for many of the health benefits of soya (see pages 10-11).
Phytic acid
Plants store their phosphate in phytic acid and it can be found in most grains, seeds and beans. Rich sources are wheat bran, flaxseed and soya. Phytic acid has been seen as a negative, anti-nutritional component because of its ability to bind minerals such as iron and zinc and therefore reduce their absorption.
However, more recent research has shown that phytic acid has many health benefits. According to scientists at the Department of Medical and Research Technology, University of Maryland School of Medicine, Baltimor USA: “…Phytic acid reduces the risk of kidney stone formation and heart disease and can act as an anticancer agent. Phytic acid works by reducing cell proliferation and increasing the differentiation of cancer cells… Recent studies show that phytic acid, even when dosed at normal levels, does not cause deficiencies or toxic effects” (Vucenik et al., 2003).
If you still want to lower your phytic acid intake, fermented soya products such as tempeh have much lower quantities – about half that of soya beans (Anderson et al., 1995).
Fab fats
Soya beans are one-fifth fat and of this, 78 per cent are the ‘good’ fats, called polyunsaturated fatty acids. In fact, the soya bean is one of the few good plant sources of the essential fatty acid, alpha-linolenic acid (ALA), an omega-3 fatty acid that the human body can’t make.
The fatty acids in soya are important hormone precursors, vital for making healthy new cells, stabilising blood pressure and promoting smooth muscle contraction.
Soya – as with all plants – is completely cholesterol-free.
Compared to cow’s milk, soya milk contains lower levels of saturated fat and higher levels of valuable unsaturated fats, which can help lower cholesterol levels.
In 2006, the American Heart Association highlighted the valuable role that soya foods can play in replacing higher-saturated-fat foods in the diet and so helping to lower blood cholesterol levels (Sacks et al., 2006).
Fibre rich
Soya beans are about one-fifth fibre – a rich source of both soluble and insoluble fibre. Both types help us but in different ways. For example, soluble fibre binds the cholesterol from food or bile acids and helps reduce the levels of ‘bad’ cholesterol in your blood. Insoluble fibre promotes a healthy pH in your intestines helping prevent colon cancer and it helps other foods to pass through your digestive system more easily and helps reduce constipation and other digestive problems such as irritable bowel syndrome (IBS).
We should eat a minimum of 18g of fibre a day yet most people in the UK eat only about 12g. A 4oz/100g serving of soya beans contains 9.3g of dietary fibre. Tofu and soya milk have little fibre, whereas edamame, tempeh and soya flour are very good sources.
Lovely lecithin
Lecithin is a fatty substance needed by every cell in our body. Cell membranes regulate what is let in, and out, of our cells and are largely made of a lecithin component called choline. Muscles, nerve cells and the protective sheath around the brain all contain it.
Lecithin and choline have many health benefits, for example helping prevent heart disease, improving brain function and memory and supporting the liver. Choline is used by the body to help remove cholesterol and aids the digestion of fats. One of the richest sources of lecithin is soya.
Vitamins and minerals
Lecithin is also an antioxidant and together with the vitamin E in soya, helps stop ‘bad’ cholesterol from oxidising and damaging arteries. Some B vitamins, including niacin (B3), pyridoxine (B6) and folate (B9), are other valuable components of soya.
Dem bones
Calcium-fortified soya products such as soya milk and tofu provide a valuable source of this important mineral without the saturated animal fat, animal protein (casein) and cholesterol found in dairy products. For example, 8fl oz/240ml of calcium-fortified soya milk provides 30 per cent of our recommended daily amount; the same as cow’s milk.
Without fortification, 4oz/100g of green, cooked soya beans (edamame) contain 145mg of calcium; 21 per cent of an adult’s daily needs. The same weight of calcium-set fried tofu contains 961mg (137 per cent of our daily needs)! An extremely good source either way.
It is sometimes claimed that the bioavailability of calcium from soya milk is not as high as from dairy milk. Scientists compared the bioavailability of cow’s milk with that of calcium-enriched soya milk and revealed that they are comparable. It follows that soya is a good source of calcium! (Zhao et al., 2005.)
Mighty magnesium
Like all minerals, magnesium cannot be made in our body and must be obtained from our diet.
About two-thirds of all the magnesium in our body is in our bones and, like calcium and phosphorus, is vital to bone health. Magnesium and calcium act together to help regulate the body’s nerve and muscle tone. Simply put, magnesium relaxes muscles while calcium contracts them.
Magnesium deficiency can trigger muscle tension and soreness, muscle spasms or cramps and muscle fatigue.
Over 300 different body enzymes need magnesium and so it follows that the functions of this mineral are particularly diverse. Magnesium is central to energy production as well as being involved in the metabolism of proteins, carbohydrates and fats. It also helps genes function correctly.
Soya is also a rich source of magnesium, with 4oz/100g containing 280mg – practically all of our daily needs. The same weight of edamame and cooked tempeh provides 22 per cent while raw tofu provides about 10 per cent.
Finally…
Soya beans are an astonishingly versatile and healthy food which can be enjoyed and savoured as part of a balanced diet. Whether it be edamame, miso soup, tofu stir-fry or a soya milk fruit smoothie – soya beans are a delightful way to add nutritious recipes to your culinary repertoire.
References
- Anderson, R.L. and Wolf, W.J. 1995. Compositional changes in trypsin inhibitors, phytic acid, saponins and isoflavones related to soybean processing. Journal of Nutrition. 125 (3 Suppl) 581S-588S.
- Campbell, T.C. and Campbell, T.M. II. 2004. The China Study. Dallas, Texas, USA: BenBella Books.
- FAO/WHO, 1989. Protein Quality Evaluation: Report of the Joint FAO/WHO Expert Consultation. Bethesda, MD (USA): Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations (Food and Nutrition Paper No. 51). 4–8 December 1989.
- Kontessis, P., Jones, S., Dodds, R., Trevisan, R., Nosadini, R., Fioretto, P., Borsato, M., Sacerdoti, D. and Viberti, G. 1990. Renal, metabolic and hormonal responses to ingestion of animal and vegetable proteins. Kidney International. 38 (1) 136-144.
- Sacks, F.M., Lichtenstein, A., Van Horn, L., Harris, W., Kris-Etherton, P. and Winston, M. 2006. Soy protein, isoflavones, and cardiovascular health: an American Heart Association Science Advisory for professionals from the Nutrition Committee. Circulation. 113 (7)1034-1044.
- Vucenik, I. and Shamsuddin, A.M. 2003. Cancer inhibition by inositol hexaphosphate (IP6) and inositol: from laboratory to clinic. Journal of Nutrition. 133, 3778S-3784S.
- Zhao, Y., Martin B.R. and Weaver, C.M. 2005. Calcium bioavailability of calcium carbonate fortified soya milk is equivalent to cow’s milk in young women. Journal of Nutrition. 135 (10) 2379-2382.
|
 |
The Soya Story - Contents
Resources:
The Soya Story
Read the online version of our guide to soya
Download the pdf
Buy the guide
The Safety of Soya
Read our fully-referenced soya fact sheet
Download the pdf
Buy the factsheet
Soya-Based Infant Formula
A safe alternative to cow's milk formula
Download the pdf
The Soya Saga
Should we be running scared or welcoming this little bean into our hearts and stew pots?
Read this article on soya from VeggieHealth issue 4
Myth-Busting
The VVF examines the soya scare-mongering stories and investigates what, if any, scientific basis there is behind them
Soya and the Environment
Soya farming is devastating the Amazon, but where does all the soya go? It's not for human consumption…
FAQs
What worries you most? Read some of our most frequently asked nutritional enquiries
Soya research
Read the scientific evidence for yourself…
|